The girls weren't too bad. They were amateurs as the title says, so they looked like normal girls and most were cute. However, the guy screwing them looked like he got in a freaking car wreak and disfigured his face. Plus he looked pregnant (don't drink and spooge). Anyway, looking at his ugly mug ruined it for me. If he was out of the movie and just the girls were left then it would be a winner for sure. But with his ugly self, spewing his goo all over the place, was just too nasty. Sickening, rather. I like cream pie stuff when it is done tastefully (if that is even possible :P).